PPE Compatibility Matters: Why Helmets, Visors, Glasses and Ear Defenders Must Work Together

Compatible JSP PPE – helmet, visor, glasses and ear defenders – Start Safety EU

On many sites one worker wears four or five items of PPE at the same time: a safety helmet, ear defenders, safety glasses or a visor, sometimes a mask. Each of them is tested and certified on its own. The problem starts when they are worn together. Glasses that lift the seal of ear defenders, a beanie that changes how the helmet sits, a visor mounted on the wrong helmet – and the protection on the label is no longer the protection you actually have.

That is why PPE compatibility matters. EU rules (Directive 89/656/EEC) require that when a worker has to wear more than one item of PPE at once, the items must be compatible and each must remain effective against its risk. In this guide we explain where the most common conflicts arise and how to build a set that works as one system.

JSP EVOGuard C2 visor mounted on a JSP EVO helmet, in use while cutting

Why "certified" is not the same as "compatible"

A helmet is tested to EN 397, ear defenders to EN 352, eye and face protection to EN 166. Each test checks one product on its own. When products are combined, they affect each other:

  • the arms of safety glasses can break the seal of ear defender cushions and let noise in;
  • headband ear defenders can't be worn properly over a helmet, and under it they push the helmet out of position;
  • a hood or ordinary hat under the helmet changes its fit and can reduce impact protection;
  • a half mask can push glasses up and make them fog;
  • a visor gives a different level of impact protection depending on what it is mounted on.

The surest way to avoid these conflicts is to choose items that the manufacturer has designed and tested to work together.

Helmet and ear defenders

If you wear a helmet, use helmet-mounted ear defenders. They clip into the side slots of the helmet, so they sit at the right angle and pressure, and they are always with you on site. When you don't need them, they flip up and rest against the helmet.

JSP EVO helmets – for example the EVO2 and the EVO3 with wheel ratchet – have universal accessory slots for JSP helmet-mounted ear defenders and visors. Choose the ear defenders by the noise level:

Model SNR Typical environment
Sonis 1 helmet-mounted 26 dB lower noise: landscaping, workshops
Sonis Compact helmet-mounted 31 dB construction and general industry; low profile
Sonis 3 helmet-mounted 36 dB very high noise: quarries, heavy engineering

More attenuation is not always better. If the ear defenders cut out too much noise, workers can't hear warning signals, reversing alarms or colleagues – and tend to take them off. The aim is a level at the ear of roughly 70–80 dB. Under EU rules, hearing protection must be made available from a daily noise exposure of 80 dB(A) and must be worn from 85 dB(A).

Helmet and visor

A visor protects the whole face from flying particles, splashes and molten metal. How well it protects also depends on how it is mounted. For example, according to JSP, the EVOGuard C2 industrial visor withstands high-energy impact (class A, 190 m/s) when mounted on a JSP EVO helmet, and 160 m/s when mounted on a browguard. The visor flips up when not in use, has anti-fog and anti-scratch coatings, and can be worn over prescription glasses and with a JSP Force 8 half mask.

Where there is no risk of falling objects and a helmet is not needed – in a workshop or at a machine – the visor and ear defenders can be worn on a browguard instead. The EVOGuard C2 browguard system combines a browguard, the C2 visor and Sonis Compact ear defenders in one tested kit.

For forestry and landscaping, the EVOGuard M2 mesh visor made of woven stainless steel fits compatible EVO helmets and browguards through the same slots and can be combined with ear defenders.

Safety glasses under ear defenders

This is the most common hidden conflict. Thick spectacle arms run under the ear cushions and create a gap through which noise enters. Three ways to avoid it:

  • Integrated glasses. JSP EVOSpec clips into the helmet – for example the EVO3 – and has no arms over the ears at all. It flips up when not needed and is always with the helmet. Clear or smoke lens, EN 166 impact rating F.
  • Glasses with thin, flat arms. The lighter and thinner the arms, the less they disturb the seal – for example JSP Stealth safety glasses weighing 16 g.
  • Goggles with a headband. The low-profile JSP EVO goggles have an elastic strap instead of arms and can be worn with a helmet or bump cap.

For people who wear prescription glasses, the JSP Stealth Coverlite overspecs fit over their own glasses and weigh only 34 g.

Mask and eye protection

A tight-fitting mask and glasses compete for the same space on the bridge of the nose. If the glasses push the mask, it stops sealing; if the mask pushes the glasses, they fog up from exhaled air. Choose eye protection designed to work with a mask: the EVO goggles and the C2 visor are both compatible with the JSP Force 8 half mask. We cover masks in detail in our guide to FFP2, FFP3 and half masks.

What goes under the helmet

Quick compatibility check

Combination Common problem Solution
Helmet + ear defenders headband defenders don't fit with the helmet helmet-mounted ear defenders for the same helmet system
Ear defenders + glasses arms break the seal, noise gets in integrated EVOSpec, thin arms or goggles
Helmet + visor visor not tested with this helmet, lower impact rating visor and helmet from the same system
Mask + glasses fogging, mask doesn't seal mask-compatible goggles or visor
Helmet + winter hat helmet sits wrongly, less protection thermal liner made for the helmet

Example sets

  • Construction site: EVO3 helmet + Sonis Compact helmet-mounted ear defenders + EVOSpec glasses.
  • Cutting and grinding: EVO helmet + C2 visor + Sonis Compact, or the C2 browguard system where no helmet is needed; with a Force 8 half mask where there is dust.
  • Forestry and landscaping: EVO helmet + M2 mesh visor + helmet-mounted ear defenders.
  • Work at height: EVO Alta Skyworker + helmet-mounted ear defenders + thin-armed safety glasses or goggles.

Frequently asked questions

Can I combine products from different brands?

Only if both manufacturers state that the combination has been tested. Helmet-mounted ear defenders and visors are tested with specific helmets, so the manufacturer's compatibility list is the guide. Choosing helmet and accessories from one system removes the guesswork.

Can I wear headband ear defenders with a helmet?

Not properly. Over the helmet the cups don't reach the ears at the right pressure, and under it the headband pushes the helmet out of position. Use helmet-mounted ear defenders.

How do I check that ear defenders still seal with my glasses?

Put on everything you will actually wear at work and check that the cushions sit flat all around the ears with no visible gap. If you wear glasses with thick arms, switch to thin-armed glasses, goggles or integrated EVOSpec.

Order compatible PPE from Start Safety EU

The JSP helmets, ear defenders, visors and glasses in this article are in stock in our warehouse in Varna. Need help putting together a compatible set for your team? Call us on +359 (0)87 8810774 or email sales@startsafety.eu – we will check the compatibility and prepare a quote.

The Start Safety EU team


Author
Sophie Ivanova
Tags
  1. PPE
What do our customers think?

What do our customers think?

Trusted by thousands who choose us every time they need safety equipment.